Question 3 Write three or four sentences explaining the dissenting point of view as expressed by Chief Justice Rehnquist and two other justices in the minority opinion. In what ways do these justices disagree with Justice Brennan? Cite textual evidence to support your answer.

Question

Question 3 Write three or four sentences explaining the dissenting point of view as expressed by Chief Justice Rehnquist and two other justices in the minority opinion. In what ways do these justices disagree with Justice Brennan? Cite textual evidence to support your answer.

Answer 1

In the dissenting opinion, Chief Justice Rehnquist and two other justices disagreed with Justice Brennan's interpretation of the Fourth Amendment. They argued that the Fourth Amendment only protects against physical searches and seizures, not digital ones. They cited textual amendment itself, which does not mention digital searches or seizures, to support their argument. Additionally, they expressed concern that broadening the interpretation of the Fourth Amendment could lead to unintended consequences and infringe upon other rights.

Problemas

Question 3 Write three or four sentences explaining the dissenting point of view as expressed by Chief Justice Rehnquist and two other justices in the minority opinion. In what ways do these justices disagree with Justice Brennan? Cite textual evidence to support your answer.

Roztwór

Respuesta