Your response may start with something similar to this:"agree with this statement. In my opinion, I feel/believe that To support my perspective, "or"I disagree with this statement. In my opinion, I feel/believe __ To support my perspective, Prompt: Opinion 1 (from Antigone, Part 1): King Creon refuses to give Antigone's brother, Polyneices, a proper burial because he betrayed the city. Antigone laments this and wants to bury her brother regardless as is her duty. However, King Creon ordered, "Anyone who acts against the order/will be stoned to death before the city." In the context of this reading, what is your opinion of King Creon's order? Opinion 2 (from Antigone, Part 1): Antigone is resolved to bury her brother,Polyneices. She asks her sister, Ismene, to help her do so, but Ismene cautions her against it because King Creon ordered that burying him is a crime.To this Antigone responds,"Yes. But he's got no right to keep me from what's mine." Do you agreè or disagree with Antigone? Explain your answer. Opinion 3 (from Antigone, Part 1): Ismene, in her attempt to dissuade Antigone from burying their brother tells her, "We must remember that by birth we're women,/and, as such, we shouldn't fight with men." Do you think this is an effective argument? Explain your answer.

Question

Your response may start with something similar to this:"agree with this statement. In my opinion, I feel/believe that To support my perspective, "or"I disagree with this statement. In my opinion, I feel/believe __ To support my perspective, Prompt: Opinion 1 (from Antigone, Part 1): King Creon refuses to give Antigone's brother, Polyneices, a proper burial because he betrayed the city. Antigone laments this and wants to bury her brother regardless as is her duty. However, King Creon ordered, "Anyone who acts against the order/will be stoned to death before the city." In the context of this reading, what is your opinion of King Creon's order? Opinion 2 (from Antigone, Part 1): Antigone is resolved to bury her brother,Polyneices. She asks her sister, Ismene, to help her do so, but Ismene cautions her against it because King Creon ordered that burying him is a crime.To this Antigone responds,"Yes. But he's got no right to keep me from what's mine." Do you agreè or disagree with Antigone? Explain your answer. Opinion 3 (from Antigone, Part 1): Ismene, in her attempt to dissuade Antigone from burying their brother tells her, "We must remember that by birth we're women,/and, as such, we shouldn't fight with men." Do you think this is an effective argument? Explain your answer.

Answer 1

I agree with Antigone's perspective in Opinion 2. In my opinion, I believe that Antigone is right in asserting that King Creon has no right to keep her from burying her brother. To support my perspective, Antigone's actions are driven by her sense of duty and loyalty to her family, which are fundamental values that should not be overridden by the orders of a ruler. Additionally, Creon's edict seems to be an overreach of power, potentially violating the moral and religious rights of the citizens. Antigone's determination to honor her brother, despite the consequences, highlights the importance of familial duty and the resistance against unjust authority.

Problemas

Roztwór

Respuesta